Loading...
Boards & Commissions Supporting Documents - 01/10/2006 - Board of Trustees• i ITEM 911192) o alkil!", H ' AGENDA ITEM Regular Board of Trustees Meeting of January 10, 2006 SUBJECT: Award of Contracts: 1 - Fiber Optic Cable Restoration 2 — Fiber Optic Construction Management — Additional Services 3 — Network Design 4 - Telecommunications System Replacement FROM: Bruce Kapff, Information Services and Purchasing Director BUDGET SOURCE/BUDGET IMPACT: Total of $255,000 budgeted in the Information Services Program #151, comprised of $225,000 from the Equipment Replacement line item — 9020, and $30,000 from the Computer Hardware and Software line item — 9160. RECOMMENDED MOTIONS: 1 — Fiber Optic Cable Restoration - I move that the Village Board award a contract for Fiber Optic Cable Restoration to the lowest responsive and responsible proposer, Adesta, LLC, Romeoville, IL. subject to staff review, for the total cost of $50,230.84, as indicated on the attached proposal tabulation (Exh #3). 2 — Fiber Optic Construction Manalzement — Additional Services - I move that the Village Board approve additional construction management services with TDSi, Naperville, IL. subject to staff review, for the added cost of $1,750, plus expenses, as indicated on the attached proposal (Exh #4). 3 — Network Design - I move that the Village Board award a contract for Network Design to TDSi, Naperville, IL. subject to staff review, for the total cost of $10,175, plus expenses, as indicated on the attached proposal (Exh #5). 4 — Telecommunications System Replacement - I move that the Village Board award a contract for Telecommunications System Replacement to the lowest responsive and responsible proposer, Sound, Inc., 'Naperville, IL. subject to staff review, for the total cost of $149,195, as indicated on the attached proposal tabulation (Exh #6). C \Documents and Settmgs\rserence \Local Settings \Temporary Internet Piles \0LK39 \Board memo - 2005 telecom fiber and network doc BackErround[History: The Village Board, at its meeting of June 28, 2005, approved contracts with TDSi for telephone and fiber consulting services and authorized staff to obtain proposals for telephone systems and fiber upgrades. Exhibit #1 — Telecommunications System Replacement Project — Board Presentation. This exhibit was prepared by TDSi to serve as an executive summary for the entire project. It covers the selection process we used to select TDSi as our consultant, their experience in providing these services, and the RFP process used by the Village and TDSi to select both a telecommunications system, as well as a contractor to upgrade our fiber optic wide area network (WAN) that extends to our outlying buildings. This summary also compares the costs associated with implementing the two primary telecom technologies, VoIP Enabled PBX vs. a full VoIP System. As indicated in the table on the second page there is a significant increase in project cost, approximately $115,000, for us to go directly to a full VoIP system at this time. In addition to the added cost for the telephone system, various buildings would need improved cabling (parts of the Village Hall, Public Works and Fire Station #2) and our entire network would require an upgrade at this time. With the recommended VoIP Enabled PBX telephone system from Sound, Inc., we get all of the desired features (current and future), plus we avoid the added costs of implementing a full VoIP system. Exhibit #2 — Fiber Optic, Network and Telecom Summary. The highlighted center of this spreadsheet shows all of the work to be completed at this time. The items proposed for approval at the December 13, 2005 meeting are so indicated. The other items listed will either come back to the Board at a future meeting, be approved by the Village Manager, or may not be needed. Exhibit #3 — Fiber Optic Upgrades, and Exhibit #6 — Telecommunications System Replacement, summarize the proposals received for each project and provide back -up for the above recommendations. Exhibit #4 — Expanded Implementation Assistance — Fiber Project. This proposal from TDSi accounts for additional construction management work than was anticipated when the original contract with TDSi was approved. It adds time for more site inspections, punch list follow -up, responding to contractor questions and an additional final inspection to verify all items have been completed correctly. Exhibit #5 — Network Design - This proposal from TDSi will look at a number of network operational and structureal items including the redesign of the IP numbering scheme and the interaction of software applications on the network. It will also provide us with possible future improvements to the network hardware and software. It is recommended that this work proceed concurrently with the other project items listed above. Recommendation: That the Village Board approve the recommended motions listed above. C \Documents and Settmgs\rserence \Local Settings \Temporary Internet Files \OLK39 \13oard memo - 2005 telecom fiber and network doc TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC. Telecommunications I Network Infrastructure Design & Consulting Whige (if Oal Brook F a d x�`��'au■�x k` 1; 76033 &ML P"d Cak Grc _k,1L 6Q.01 WS Village of Oakbrook Telecommunications System Replacement Project Board Presentation — January 10, 2006 The Project Background 1. The Village rented Centrex services from SBC for years. 2. The Village recently determined that purchasing their own telecommunications system would add needed features and reduce operating costs. 3. The Village identified numerous problems and issues with the existing Fiber Optic cable currently installed. 4. The Village examined numerous ways to address these issues 5. The Village decided to retain an independent consulting firm. 6. Competitive proposals for consultants were obtained. 7. Village Staff worked with TDSi to estimate Telecommunications. 8. Technical Design Services, Inc. (TDSi) was retained. TDSi Background 1. TDSi is an independent IT consulting firm specializing in Voice Communications Consulting, Data Network Consulting and Cable Infrastructure Design Services. 2. TDSi does not sell any hardware or software and does not represent any vendors. 3. TDSi has performed these specific IT consulting services for more than 150 municipalities and government agencies nation -wide. 4. TDSi's staff has deep experience in providing these services The Process Phase 1 — Village Telecommunications Needs Assessment. 1. TDSi worked with Village Staff and Department Heads to perform a System Needs Assessment. 2. TDSi compared the existing telecommunications system arrangements to general alternatives. 3. TDSi Cable Specialists reviewed the Village's existing Fiber Optic Cable. 4. TDSi prepared a cost comparison presentation of findings and recommendations. 1075 SHORE ROAD, SUITE A • NAPERVILLE, IL 60563 • 630.983.9908 www.tdsinc.biz TEL 630 983.9906 FAX Y t TT i �mOx 11 000 fide P—d CLk R­* IL 60F2'.Z55 January 10, 2006 Board Presentation Phase 2 — Competitive SystemNendor Selection 1. TDSi prepared a formal Request For Proposal (RFP). 2. The RFP specifications were developed to allow all equipment vendors a chance to participate. 3. RFP document was distributed by Village to all interested vendors 4. Interested Vendors attended a mandatory Village sponsored Pre - Proposal Vendor Conference to answer questions. 5. 12 Vendor Proposals were received. 6. TDSi reviewed all Vendor Proposals. 7. TDSi gathered clarifications from vendors. 8. TDSi prepared documentation regarding the vendor proposals. 9. TDSi reviewed the findings with the Village Staff. 10. TDSi compared the impact of deployment of pure VoIP and VolP Enabled PBX system using the City's facilities and infrastructure. General Cost Comparison The Proiect Findings 1. Village Staff and TDSi determined that the implementation of a VolP Enabled PBX will address the Villages' current and future operational needs. 2. Village Staff and TDSi determined that the implementation of a VolP Enabled PBX is within the Village's budgetary requirements and provides the best long and short -term value. TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC. Page 2 VolP Enabled VolP PBX System Cable upgrade $ 55,855 00 $ 70,855 00 Network Upgrade $ 51,599 00 $136,54300 Voice Equipment $137,29200 $152,06800 TOTAL $244,746.00 $ 359,466.00 Budget Cable $ 30,000 00 $ 30,000 00 Voice Equipment $225,00000 $225,00000 TOTAL $255,000.00 $ 255,000.00 Net to Budget $ 10,254.00 $(104,466.00) The Proiect Findings 1. Village Staff and TDSi determined that the implementation of a VolP Enabled PBX will address the Villages' current and future operational needs. 2. Village Staff and TDSi determined that the implementation of a VolP Enabled PBX is within the Village's budgetary requirements and provides the best long and short -term value. TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC. Page 2 i 9P Y0ti � PYY IEI]OeB m�A P-4 O'k%n * IL 8C&&=. January 10, 2006 Board Presentation 3. Village Staff and TDSi determined that the use of a VoIP Enabled PBX best fits into the Village's existing infrastructure providing the Village with a high degree of operational and budgetary flexibility. Proiect Recommendations 1. Purchase and implement the VoIP Enabled PBX Systems proposed by Sound Incorporated. i. These systems meet all of the current and foreseeable future operational requirements for the Village. ii These systems provide the Village with a migration path to further implement VoIP technologies if ever needed to meet the business applications of the Village. iii The system design using this equipment applies VolP in a strategic fashion, using VolP technology in the backbone of the network and to Golf Maintenance, Sports Core and Bath and Tennis Club iv. The Maintenance arrangement proposed provides high value for the Village. 2. Implement Changes to the Fiber Optic Cable currently installed. 3 Conduct further Network Assessment and Design Work i. This project is related to addressing a number of network operational and structure items including the redesign of the IP numbering scheme, software application and interaction, etc ii. The system costs outlined above address the network requirements to deploy VoIP. The work outlined here addresses additional network consulting. TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC. Page 3 E E co O Y a) O (13 N >z U Q O z�h �a Q) U_ a) CO C O a) `O ` o -a c 0 � o m m � m � a) c� a) 0 a) 0 Q o_ E E O C: 0 0 O () a) > O 4-- *. 4- Q CL a E a) 0) c c a o -0o E o� a) �� a) o O m m m 0 0 cy') N 4-- N O N (D -0 - N cB cn > O > > > > O a) V � a) � L +r v- C C U O o o — U 2 � -a U) Y N _ Y _ U) 32 Z) _0 ❑ ❑ O <1 I I l< f- ❑ ❑ co OM F; 00 O O O 0p O Q) C O O O to (O (o d' M O to O O r- 0 N O f` (O E O d N O 00 rn c0 Q (f) 64 64 co c- 64 'T LO 'Q 64 64 64 64 N 64 C 0 0 0 0 q O LO LO LO LO 0 0 Lo LO 0 0 0) O O G O t6-- O O O O O 00 r- (f) to to Lo O O 00 r O O 0) O O O O Nor O O O O O O � � O In O O U7 � of O O O Iq 000000(000 IgIglz �t�t0r-0) O O 0) t- OOO 1` Lo O � O F- O) LO Lo O O O d' to r- O t` Ln O r 0) t` O O O to O LO 1- I- c- N 6g M 64 64 — 64 to 00 64 �h 6p* I' 64 � 64 d 64 r- 64 — 00 64 e- to Cf Iq co LO M N LO 64 64 61} 64 64 V- e- N 64 N N r 64 EA 691 64 69 U m .O L a a_ a_ v7 cn U m U) X U U) 0- (Da O U) a) � ❑ C N =� -0 ❑ O4- O r 0 U U (n m fn (Uj U \ 3 ~ ots � U N C (6 L11 Z c N a) L) 06 m N (Q o E Co U cn m U O O co c' 0 � U o M a) 70 L a X X O U m 4, O O ❑ ,L z m CO a mO2 U O Q > u) v) 2i n cn— o Y Q B 13- E-° CO O Q ON a) m a � > o v �.. �• ) O �o 0 Q*'±' a) ZZZZZ a) a) a) Z a) _ IL o � - mQ= N � z > n 7E; J i u' ° z cs a a z�h �a Q) U_ a) CO C O a) December 6, 2005 Mr Bruce Kapff Information Services Director Purchasing Director CPPB Village of Oak Brook 1200 Oak Brook Road Oak Brook, IL 60523 Dear Mr. Kapff: The Village of Oak Brook and Technical Design Services, Inc. (TDSi) are in the process of evaluating contractor proposals for the Fiber Optic Restoration Project. In reviewing the contractor proposals TDSi is recommending that the Village of Oak Brook award the Fiber Optic Restoration Project to Adesta (contractor). Adesta has the lowest proposal price and from our detailed scope review and subsequent meeting they appear to have a complete understanding of the overall project. The overall project, at a total construction cost of $50,230.84, will consist of the following items as detailed in the proposal response: 1. Base Sum Price: $16,721.48 • Multimode re- termination and testing, singlemode termination and testing and 12- strand multimode fiber optic repair at hand hole 4' ) 5. 2. Alternate #1: $61577.61 • Replace deficient exterior junction boxes with new "outdoor rated" junction boxes. 3. Alternate #2: $3,566.94 • Elevate and re -work existing hand hole device box #25. 4. Alternate #3: $17)504.81 • New outdoor pathway between GMB and SCA. 5. Hand Hole Device Box Upgrade Work: $520.00 ea. (Four Hand holes $2,080.00) 6. Rework locate wires throughout pathway system: $3,780.00 • Splice all locate wires throughout pathway system and provide four areas along route for locate equipment connection. 1075 SHORE ROAD, SUITE A • NAPERVILLE, IL 60563 • TEL 630 983 9906 FAx 630 983 9908 www tdsinc biz Z� X 3 I;CHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC. Telecommunications I Network `sA'xt`a! is aY , Infrastructure Desigii & Considtiilg December 6, 2005 Mr Bruce Kapff Information Services Director Purchasing Director CPPB Village of Oak Brook 1200 Oak Brook Road Oak Brook, IL 60523 Dear Mr. Kapff: The Village of Oak Brook and Technical Design Services, Inc. (TDSi) are in the process of evaluating contractor proposals for the Fiber Optic Restoration Project. In reviewing the contractor proposals TDSi is recommending that the Village of Oak Brook award the Fiber Optic Restoration Project to Adesta (contractor). Adesta has the lowest proposal price and from our detailed scope review and subsequent meeting they appear to have a complete understanding of the overall project. The overall project, at a total construction cost of $50,230.84, will consist of the following items as detailed in the proposal response: 1. Base Sum Price: $16,721.48 • Multimode re- termination and testing, singlemode termination and testing and 12- strand multimode fiber optic repair at hand hole 4' ) 5. 2. Alternate #1: $61577.61 • Replace deficient exterior junction boxes with new "outdoor rated" junction boxes. 3. Alternate #2: $3,566.94 • Elevate and re -work existing hand hole device box #25. 4. Alternate #3: $17)504.81 • New outdoor pathway between GMB and SCA. 5. Hand Hole Device Box Upgrade Work: $520.00 ea. (Four Hand holes $2,080.00) 6. Rework locate wires throughout pathway system: $3,780.00 • Splice all locate wires throughout pathway system and provide four areas along route for locate equipment connection. 1075 SHORE ROAD, SUITE A • NAPERVILLE, IL 60563 • TEL 630 983 9906 FAx 630 983 9908 www tdsinc biz Z� X 3 a O W o'/ ■ o ^V W Ilia L a. a Lo T L V/ d n AA �L+ ^W .i.i O O m O 0 o O o 0 00000 w 0000 O 00000 N 0 0 0 r 0 0 0 0 0 N M (D O- >+ u 0000 O O O O O O V ti M 0 69 r O 00 U7 Cl) O (D IT O (O to (0 U) Cl) U) V O 00 V7 O U) It r` O U) r •- (n O N O tt O N (D - O 00 C4 u r N M N- ul M Ui 60 M <- 69 N 69 69 d9 69 E9 69 64 64 W X W O O O r 000-- 0 0 (() O O 00 0) 0 r ; 00 IT U7 qT - U) O r- O O Y N O O O O OD M r- 0 0 N 0'IT 0 O O v U) O U) 69 r Cl) 0- U) r- M o N cM (r) 3 C OD r- N CIO M L6 69 o'i r- O 00 N ti O (6 N C4 O) V- M O N U) N U) O M E9 c 2 y (n r N e- 64 69 N 6% EA e- m Z C E9 HT 69 04 V> 6A U). N A O 2 N c d L O w 7 cn ° m m > o ° z a- 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 w 0000 0 0 0 0 0 0 (n000(n 00000 0(n0o(n m p 0000 0000 0 0 U r 9 �t N E r 0 U) N N rl_ U) M O U7 N r OO P.: Mtl- CO N r (Ot- NfArl U7 IT O U) O r- MN (O V _ d i r N EA 69 vl! - 69 69 04 69 69 .-- 6A 69 � 60-6.1 69 m m 0 N d Y 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Cl) 0000 0 00rl_ 0n 000rl_ rl_ T 0000 0 o U.) v o vi u) (n L) v 0) p 00 0 0 0 C N m O N 00 69 (D V .- O V rf .- N c0 (D 0o v M O) U) O O U) O O O O O 00 LO V 0 p y L 00 Lf) V7 69 ffl N M (f) V r U) r 69 69 to N r 06'611 M N FA N E9 0 in m0 69 69 69 6% 69 69 ` ma cU 0 O N CO 7 C: i O p l0 o_ U v o' d E U � 0 0 0 0 Cl 0 0 0 0 0 (n 0 0 0 0 O O O O O Co 0 0 0 0 0 >1 CID 0000 O U) O O O O O (0 N N O O C o c o O c 0 OD r-r-69N coM(n co (D ONrl- N Cl) U)MU)00 IT OOOO rnrn Cl) 0) U) lT .a O OD T .- ' M ER O M 1 W 69 N 2 r- 69 r E9 EA r 61) 61) - 69 64 691 M N 64 64 Q, C Q � Q E E 0 U (n r- (D o co 0 (o r� (D co w v T O O 00 (n O of M U) O r OM)CD6fiN (D � U) U) IT Cl) O r- U7 •- MU)r- ON 0 _ (0 0) M M t- co 'IT I' 1`(0 0 N O O N r M CO r- r` r- 06 (c 69 6% r M M 00 - r� o L6 w. 6a m 69 U7 o c- U) U) U) Cl) m cli r- 69 69 U) N 69 69 6% 69 69 m Q m' �w '�' cn�M ° � o �0 M 0 CL -6 O L L L m J ~ (D N O 7 d CL d CL m m F- H U m (n C,6 C45 - w = = = 0 00 G - cnU)U)cn 0 0) 0) Ui o 0 m - L i6 io m w w w w m m m m o m m m m V E E LL- 0 0 0 0 > N N H F- 0 N N E Q Q Q Q O ; 0 O '06 N U °) -o m 2? m W E ;-- c c O 0- U 2 5 (�'� o2m 65 U a W 2 Z G @(D� 2 a) U) M L O N G 'C CL O 0 j N O 7 m a y 2 O W >. a) yo ci N m M CID a) Z@ y 2 ti d 7 O � N d N N d Q Z ci 0 E ca C N # V v7 CL 0 o a c (L) O C CO) V ` C Q c a E 0`60 �i m Q Q U a; � , v r Tc-c N£IC4L Dr-SIGN SCRVICES, INC. " s.3ti £ <x e 3 3a ,fir. "= „h,< e i� 77 ;;; _ IIIfriisiruc,ture Desagrl & Coitsultirtg December 6, 2005 Mr. Bruce F. Kapff Information Services Director Purchasing Director CPPB Village of Oak Brook 1200 Oak Brook Road Oak Brook, Illinois 60523 -2255 Re: Expanded Implementation Assistance (Fiber Optic Restoration Project) Dear Bruce Technical Design Services, Inc (TDSi) is pleased to offer you this proposal for expanded Implementation Assistance Services for the Fiber Optic Restoration Project. We have enjoyed working with you during the design phase of this important project and would like to offer Implementation Assistance Services for the construction portion of the project. We have provided a detailed explanation of the work that could be included in the final phase of this project and have also provided the approximate amount of time associated with each of the tasks and have assigned a value to all of the services The following provides you with specific information about the work that we are proposing and our team approach to your project We look forward to meeting with you to discuss this proposal further. If you have any questions or require any additional information regarding this proposal, please call me at 630.388.6580 Sincerely, TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC. Brett Mersch 1075 SHORE ROAD, SUITE A NAPER VILLE, IL 60563 -8758 TEL: 630.983.9906 Fax: 630 983.9908 \vww tdsine biz �d MR. BRUCE KAPFF CONSULTING SERVICES PROPOSAL VILLAGE OF OAK BROOK IMPLEMENTATION ASSISTANCE SERVICES FIBER OPTIC RESTORATION PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION ASSISTANCE SERVICES PROPOSAL UNDERSTANDING OF PROJECT SCOPE The Village of Oak Brook is in the process of restoring their fiber optic cabling infrastructure Technical Design Services, Inc (TDSi) has been involved with the design of the restoration project and has been requested by the Village of Oak Brook to provide a proposal for Expanded Implementation Assistance for this project The services covered in this proposal include attending a pre - construction meeting, punch -list creation for all accepted alternatives and oversight and final project acceptance Each of the items are detailed and associated with an approximate number of hours to complete the task A limited number of periodic site reviews, test report and as -built reviews are covered under our existing scope of work with the Village Please refer to the following Project Methodology which details the work steps involved in the Implementation Assistance. PROJECT METHODOLOGY This proposal represents a proven methodology and approach for the Implementation Assistance portion of the construction project The work proposed in this proposal is intended to compliment the work proposed in the Design Services Proposal. The following details provide the approximate number of hours associated with each task: Expanded Implementation Assistance Once a contractor has been selected it is essential that their work be monitored to insure the system is installed per plans and specifications TDSi is able to provide these services and offers the following steps. 1. Pre - construction meeting. TDSi will meet with the cabling contractor prior to construction beginning to clarify any questions and set the basis for understanding the design and intent of the systems to be installed During this meeting, project scheduling will be discussed Additional construction meetings can be accommodated and will be billed on a T &M basis Approximate Time: 3 Hours 2. Create punch list and punch list oversight. TDSi will assist the Village of Oak Brook with monitoring the contractor's installation to assure that it follows the designed plans and specifications. Based on increased size and scope of this project, TDSi is suggesting additional work effort will be required to verify the installation quality of the system. Near the completion of the project TDS1 will conduct a walkthrough of the installation to develop a final punch list of items for the TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC Page 2 MR BRUCE KAPFF CONSULTING SERVICES PROPOSAL VILLAGE OF OAK BROOK IMPLEMENTATION ASSISTANCE SERVICES contractor to correct prior to final acceptance of the project by the Village of Oak Brook TDSi then proposes to work with the Village and the contractor to implement the punch list items and answer any related questions. When the contract states that all punch list items have been resolved, TDSi will again inspect the installation and verify that these items have indeed been resolved and that the system is complete Recommended hours • 11 hours ■ Substantial completion walk - through - 4 Hours ■ Develop punch list - 2 Hours ■ Contractor questions and answer - 2 Hours ■ Final inspection and verification - 3 Hours PROJECT TIMING TDSi will schedule site reviews based on the contractor's schedule of the outlined milestones as discussed at the pre - construction meeting TDS1 will also make any reasonable attempt to attend other meeting / site reviews requested by the owner based on the above outlined project methodology PROJECT FEES Our fees reflect the experience and expertise of each individual that would be assigned to the project The time and resources allocated are determined based upon our understanding of the specific requirements of the project, as explained in the project scope. These services will be available on a Time and Material basis. The Village of Oak Brook will decide which portions of this proposal they will require and will direct TDS1 accordingly. Should there be significant changes in the scope or required methodology, we would inform The Village of Oak Brook of the required change in our fees before proceeding Direct expenses will be billed in addition to our fees. The fees for completion of Implementation Assistance Services are based on the estimated time of 13 hours to complete the requested work. 1. Our fee for this project is: 0 $1,750.00. (Plus expenses not detailed above) Payment terms, unless agreed upon otherwise: We will issue an invoice for our services rendered on a monthly basis or when the pricing documents are issued. The fees will be payable upon receipt. 2. Additional services and work performed that is out of scope will be billed as Time and Expenses at a rate of $95.00 /hr — $125.00/hr depending on the individuals performing the task. TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC Page 3 MR BRUCE KAPFF VILLAGE OF OAK BROOK Acceptance of Proposal CONSULTING SERVICES PROPOSAL IMPLEMENTATION ASSISTANCE SERVICES If the scope and arrangements outlined in this proposal are acceptable, please sign a copy and return to us or issue a Purchase Order for the fees listed above. Once authorization from the Village is received, we will establish a project schedule with you and proceed with the project. We appreciate this opportunity and look forward to working with you. Consulting Services Proposal for The Village of Oak Brook — Fiber Optic Restoration Project — Implementation Assistance Services Accepted by. The Village of Oak Brook Authorized Signature Name /Title , 2005 Consulting Services Proposal for The Village of Oak Brook — Fiber Optic Restoration Project — Implementation Assistance Services Accepted by TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC. Brett Mersch, Senior Consultant December 6, 2005 TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC Page 4 3r >' >�;F F 'rel'GL)tYf11tunications Network Infrastructure De,5ts n &Consulting ,r + + December 6, 2005 Mr. Bruce F. Kapff Information Services Director Purchasing Director CPPB Village of Oak Brook 1200 Oak Brook Road Oak Brook, Illinois 60523 -2255 Re: Fiber Optic Campus Backbone Dear Bruce: We felt yesterday's meeting to determine the next steps for the Village of Oak Brook's infrastructure improvement was productive. The meeting generated a clear direction for moving forward that will provide for a measured introduction of new technologies into the Village in a cost effective manner. Based on our meeting, Technical Design Services, Inc. (TDS1) is pleased to offer the following proposal to the Village for assisting in the design of a new network infrastructure to support voice and data services for the Village. Proiect Background The Village has an installed base of multimode and singlemode fiber that connects the majority of their facilities on the campus bounded by Jorie Boulevard, York Road, 31St Street, and 22 "d Street. The Village has entertained proposals to upgrade the fiber installation and will proceed with upgrades over the next two months. At the same time, the Village will be replacing the existing telecommunications system with a new system that utilizes the data network to provide voice services to the majority of sites served by fiber. While the existing network can support Voice over IP (VoIP), an upgrade to the data network will improve the network's capabilities. It also appears to be prudent to review current network performance prior to implementing any voice services over the data network. The following proposal describes a cooperative network review and design process that will meet the Villages desire for improved data network services to the sites served by fiber and review current network performance. Proiect Scope Based on our walk- through and subsequent discussions, we believe we can assist the Village with the above referenced activities. Following is our understanding of the requested scope of services the Village would like us to perform: • Develop a detailed data network design to support the implementation of voice over the data network from the Government Center to the sites served by fiber optic cable. • Advise in the procurement of all necessary components of the above data network design. 1075 SHORE ROAD, SUITE NAPERVILLE, IL 60563 -8758 TEL: 630.983.9906 Fax: 630.983.9908 www tdsinc biz Mr Bruce Kapff Consulting Services Proposal Village of Oak Brook Data Network Design • Develop a budgetary design for a future upgrade of the data network at the Government Center campus • In conjunction with Village staff, conduct a review of data network performance and develop a course of action to improve the network as necessary based on any issues found and information technology best practices. • Assist the Village with project management of the selected contractor's work. We will visit the site periodically, answer questions and review project close -out materials. Proiect Worksteps This proposal represents a proven methodology and approach for the Network Design and Review project. The work proposed in this proposal will compliment the work, TDSi is already engaged in for telecommunications systems implementation and fiber optic systems improvements. The following details provide the approximate number of hours associated with each task: 1. Network Performance Review Meeting. TDSi will meet with Village staff to document any current network performance issues In addition to documenting these issues, TDSi will work with the Village to isolate any symptoms for these issues and develop a set of actionable steps for determining the root cause of the problems. Tom Jakobsen will lead the meeting and document the steps; Pete Graziano will provide additional network and operating system expertise Approximate Total Time: 8 • Tom Jakobsen — 4 Hours • Peter Graziano — 4 Hours 2. Network Performance Investigation. In conjunction with Village staff, TDSi will spend up to sixteen (16) hours conducting detailed investigations to specifically identify the root cause of any network performance issues. The result of this workstep will be the immediate resolution of any issues that may be quickly resolved or a listing of next steps that will be required for resolution. Approximate Total Time: 16 hours ■ Peter Graziano— 16 Hours 3. Network Design Meeting. TDSi will assist the Village of Oak Brook in the detailed design of a replacement data network for the sites served by fiber optic cabling. The design will be developed jointly by TDSi staff and Village technical staff. The design process will include a high -level design meeting that will discuss network connectivity alternatives, necessary features and functions and potential systems providers for the overall network. TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC Page 2 Mr. Bruce Kapff Consulting Services Proposal Village of Oak Brook Data Network Design Approximate Total Time: 6 hours ■ Tom Jakobsen — 3 Hours ■ Brett Mersch — 3 Hours 4. Development of Network Design and Future Phases. Following the network design meeting, TDSi will develop a detailed network design for the site to be served by fiber optic cabling and a high level budgetary design for the Government Center. This design will consist of physical network diagrams, virtual network diagrams and bills of material with expected purchase prices. Also in this workstep, TDSi will develop a logical progression of project phases that incorporates the resolution of all identified network performance issues and future infrastructure improvements required to prepare the Village for the implementation of next generation applications. Approximate Total Time: 24 hours ■ Tom Jakobsen — 16 Hours ■ Peter Graziano — 4 Hours ■ Brett Mersch — 4 Hours 5. Network Design and Future Phases Presentation. When we have completed the network design and have created a list of future infrastructure improvement phases, we will present the design and future plans to the Village for discussion and comment. We expect the discussion to be lively and we have included time in this step for revisions to the design and the future phases as directed by the Village. Approximate Total Time: 8 hours ■ Tom Jakobsen — 5 Hours ■ Peter Graziano — 3 Hours 6. Network Equipment Procurement Advice At this time, the Village expects to use an existing multi -state purchasing agreement to procure the equipment included in the design. TDSi will provide technical advice during the procurement process, assisting with recommendations for alternates as needed Approximate Total Time: 2 hours ■ Tom Jakobsen — 2 Hours TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC Page 3 Mr. Bruce Kapff Village of Oak Brook Project Time Schedule Consulting Services Proposal Data Network Design We estimate that the consulting and design project will take no longer than four weeks to complete. Events that could delay the project would include extended times for review and approval of design documents, changes to the scope of services to be performed, changes or delays caused by other Village projects being performed simultaneously, etc. Should such events occur, we will inform the Village of any expected delays In completing the project. Project Fees Our fees reflect the experience and expertise of each individual that will be assigned to the project. The time and resources allocated are determined based upon our understanding of the specific requirements of the project as explained in the project scope. Should there be changes in the scope or required methodology, we will inform the Village of the required change in our fees. Direct expenses, such as the plotting of a reasonable number of drawing sets for internal review, are included in our price. The fees for completion of the Data Network Design and Review project are based on the estimated time of 64 hours to complete the requested work. 1. Our fee for this project is: • $10,175.00. (Plus expenses not detailed above) Payment terms, unless agreed upon otherwise: We will issue an invoice for our services rendered on a monthly basis. The fees will be payable upon receipt 2. Additional services and work performed that is out of scope will be billed as Time and Expenses at a rate of $125.00 /hr — $175.00/hr depending on the individuals performing the task. Acceptance of Proposal If the scope and arrangements outlined in this proposal are acceptable, please sign a copy and return to us or issue a Purchase Order for the fees listed above. Once authorization from the Village is received, we will establish a project schedule with you and proceed with the project. We appreciate this opportunity and look forward to working with you. Consulting Services Proposal for The Village of Oak Brook — Data Network Design and Review Accepted by The Village of Oak Brook Authorized Signature Name /Title POOR Consulting Services Proposal for The Village of Oak Brook — Data Network Design and Review Accepted by- TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC. Tom Jakobsen, Practice Leader December 6, 2005 TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC Page 4 Mr. Bruce Kapff Village of Oak Brook Consulting Services Proposal Data Network Design If you require further information or have questions, please do not hesitate to call me at 630 -388- 6581. We look forward to working with you. Sincerely, Technical Design Services, Inc. Tom Jakobsen Practice Leader TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC Page 5 TECHNICAL Dr -SIGN SERVICES, INC. Telecorrrruunicatro)is /Network Infrastructure Design & Consulting December 8, 2005 Mr. Bruce F. Kapff Information Services Director Purchasing Director CPPB Village of Oak Brook 1200 Oak Brook Road Oak Brook, Illinois 60523 -2255 Re: Telecommunications System Recommendation Dear Bruce: Technical Design Services, Inc. (TDSi) has completed its analysis of the telecommunications proposals received by the Village of Oak Brook. As you know, we released a Request for Proposal (RFP) specification in October to number of potential vendors and eighteen (18) different organizations attended the mandatory pre -bid conference and site survey. Eleven (11) of these organizations choose to submit proposals for the Village -wide telecommunications system. In fact, one vendor, SBC, submitted an alternate proposal. The twelve (12) alternatives are summarized on the attached spreadsheet. All twelve (12) proposals for the Village -wide telecommunications system would fulfill the needs of the Village, yet they ranged in price from a low of approximately $133,000 to a high of over $260,000. The proposals included most of the major manufacturers of telecommunications equipment and included Voice over IP (VoIP), traditional Time Division Multiplexing (TDM) or combinations of both technologies. Two of the proposals offered a partially outsourced telecommunications system as an alternative. The proposed outsourced telecommunications services alternatives have a different annual utility cost structure as well as different annual maintenance costs. Therefore, a total cost of ownership was computed by adding the initial purchase price, the annual maintenance cost and estimated utility costs together for periods of 5, 7, and 10 years to determine if which alternative will be less costly over the long run. Also, the VoIP alternatives would have required a minor enhancement to the Village's data network. The costs for this enhancement were computed and added to the VoIP alternatives. The results are shown on the attached document. There are other factors which should be considered in a decision of this nature. These include: the installed base of the product proposed, the products acceptance, ease of implementation within the industry, manufacturer stability, and the technical depth of the distributor who represents the product. TDSi used these criteria to score each proposal, applied agreed upon factor weights and totaled the scores. As shown on the attached spreadsheet, the NEC proposal from Sound, Inc. received the highest score. 1075 SHORE ROAD, SUITE A NAPER VILLE, IL 60563 -8758 TEL: 630.983.9906 Fax: 630.983.9908 www tds►nc biz r J Mr. Bruce Kapff Village of Oak Brook Telecommunications Systems Recommendation Therefore, we recommend the purchase of the NEC system as bid by Sound, Inc. After the committee met with Sound, Inc. they decided that certain enhancements could be cost effectively added to the original proposal. These include a slightly more expensive, but greatly enhanced function telephone set, and an enhanced software package that allows access to more system information. This increases the total cost to $149,195.00. If you require further information or have questions, please do not hesitate to call me at 630- 388 -6582. We look forward to working with you. Sincerely, Technical Design Services, Inc. Thomas Weiman, Consulting Services Practice Leader cc: Bernie Schaaf TECHNICAL DESIGN SERVICES, INC Page 2 c 0 .i Q E 0 U 0 Q 0 L CL .0 I 19 0 M0 W J4 m 0 4- 0 0 CD R J O O O O O O p O 0 0 O CI p O O O O O O O L O. O O O. O O O O O C O O p O O O p O U) O O O O O N r O O C C O O Co 0 O O 0 0 p (o O r M O w I' 00 00 00 r O N (') M CO CO M M M M CM M 6A r n r r M 69 6A 6A 649, CA 69 69 to 69 69 O O fA 603, 69 p Ln O 'T O,t O M 00 CD O M Kj (o 0 It N 7 V O 00 M M M p O r- if N M N o0 "t L N- 't OD V M R (D r- to M— (n M C � r N N N N M N M (o M 69 69 6A N O M M IT M— O M N N (o N(o .-- N O N M 0 C'7 (o N M (O N— n O N N O N r- M M 00 O r- 1,- CO (n C') (o M v- M " N 0 n Lo � a0 M CO r (n C — CD r EA EA EA EA 6A E9 69 ER EA M 0 EA Lo O (6) M (1) co O M N (o O O (o O T O O I` M (o M OI:r IT O IT Nr M T Lo 00 M ,Kr M M CLo O N O a .o .D C'7 .- r- I` I` M U) =3 7 p N 6A 6A N C C to N O h I` M v M O t` N 64 EA 69 69 61) 64 U) 69 0— M tl- � f` r- 00 00 O M M N (O ti (o N M to M O Vt M N�- (O — r (O O M O O et CO UI M co I` U7 V' (o N (o CN co O O M — ti M U) Lo M (O p M N M O V' ei' u7 N O N 69 6A 60 69 6fi EA W. 69 69 M O (o N M U) — O W Lo r M M O t- N 619,16A 1 61). 160, 1 6A 1 6A 69 6%169 1 69 I 6A 69 O IT 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 O Oq- 0 0 0 0 N O 00 O M— M M M M O'a W U) N (o N M N M M O o O M M M W O M N to ti O r- 'd' M O (D Co -- O a N U U) w M N N 00 69 69 6A O `- 00 O M 6A 1 6916S 160311 U9 164 6A 1 V> 1 16'J I E9 40 CD M M M M M O M M O M tI_ U) U) U) 0 (o M M M O O M CD I` — O V I` CO M — O p M M O U) M� (O r- M (OA M Lo M N ti (ti U) 11) N tb M M N p- N 60- 69 601) 613, 111110 6A 691 1 6A 61 FA ER (n Co O h ct — CI) M O r- 00 ti 00 N U) CO M N O (o O M IT N d' U) M — O 00 O CO O M (D t7 (O O M M n U) t- r-- (o CO O M M 00 00 'a O O O O r- O co (o M CD r '- M O O 00 M ( j M Co N M M M V N O Lo L (N7 T M V' O N EA 6A 69 E9 69 EA 6ri 6A 6A w 6A 6A 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O O V' M O IT It CO M 000 w N C O r O V' (o ti O (o C r- O O I N 0 Vt ti 0 0 (n N It N M r- W U) (o O N M CV p COO M (f M N M? co M � M r 69 69 6% 69 69 69 69 69 6A 69 W. 6R O M M 00 co O O D It (o M IN — O N O O M "t3 M 'D 'o O 'D M V Co M EA 69 6A I U3,169, a) -'T 0'O "OOMcn V O O ° M U O U U U O U M M c- r O C C C C M CD q- O r 6si 6A 0 0 6A 69 64 6R 69 lull r- N CD M V' O M U') M N— `-' (MO V M h VO' V 0 O co O N V (D 00 N N N N N ONO M O 00 T M V t` (o '14 (n 00 (n O to M 00 It N M Lo qr 06 M 69 6A 6A 6R r r r U) 6A N T- 6ri 69 0 Lo 6A 6A 69 69 69 6R M M (D 00 O IT U') .- O N co M N M M ct IT V' •- O U) 00 00 O (o O N O V N M co M [t .-- r- (o p� M O— — 0 (D 0 (D O — M CM O N CD p M Lf t` CV O N U) p 06,6 CV M M p M co 00 V U C T. N r CA 6% E9 69 69 613, 61). 61% 64 E9 6A 69 69 ER 6A 6A U Z. C: U N C O O E c= co c CU 2 p) O U ca O QHn L m L O O w m V U) U N C-6 N-J U O V' U) } O > � O OLU (p > LL `— M CO O M O M U) to U io-2 1` F M M 'o CO L— N a -t (D (D !!= O N 00 (n — N N O CL U co b C O m U) N c M V 6A era 64 6A 69 N U 69 69 6A 69 O O O O O O p O 0 0 O O O p O O O O O O O O O O O O O O. O O O O O O p O O p O O O p O U) O O O O O O O O O O O Co O O C C O O Co 0 O O 0 0 p (o oc 00 00 00 M O w I' 00 00 00 r (') M CO CO M M M M CM M M r n r r M r 6A 6A 649, CA 69 69 to 69 69 69 1 69 fA 603, 69 'T O,t O M 00 CD O M Kj (o 0 It N � ,,:'I O t- "Z� M t- CO t- N M M M p O r- if N M N o0 "t L N- 't OD V M R (D r- to M— (n M u) 1` r N N N N M N M (o M M M W N M v 6A EA 69 69 EA 6A EA EA 6ri 6R 6A 6A V) 6A N 00 00 O O OD CD 00 M � a0 M CO r CO O O O O O N O O V O O O h M 0 N N 0 0 N N 0 0 N O 0( N N 0 0 V N co D N N O O O M (o O O (o O T O O ('7 M M (o r. OI:r IT 'Ir M IT Nr M T V N M It CD 64,69 609 6A 0) 6A vl� 64169160169164 6A 6A N O co N V 00 (o N O h I` M v M O t` M N M U) r w O O 00 N N U) O It O N M zT r rr- .- N N M O W V CM N .-- 111' (O N et M p M M CM M N - 11- t` r (o tl �- CD M M M M N I N 'IT "t 'V' � U7 (1) Lo CD 69 6A 6A 01 69 69 6A 60 69 6fi EA W. 69 69 M O (o O r- n M U) — O W Lo r M M O t- M G M tD I,- M N M O N w "T O CO O (o M r I- N N 'I- (o N't O M O m Cd N M 01 M U) N— CM m M M O (v) M M (o M (M M V' M M V M N U) M c N CD C7 O V' M C M N V U) U) (f) W IT M (O M I` U7 t- t- 00 6A E9 E9 6ti EA E9 69 6A (A 6A 6A 69 69 6A O O O 00 O r- N N M CD M r O O O N M (O ti M 'T (o N ti M r N O M Lo IT O p M (f) M) (o Nr O p M N O M ,:t I` 0 O ", (o V' w -- - (o M (- V A N (D M (o N N M N - I` N V' U) n 00 O p N 'q- (o r7 M— N N N N (o N M M M M N M 6A 69 1 69 1 69 1 6A 169 Q% 1 6A 1 6A 691 6) 69 1 (a 1 69 O O ti O N (O M M O M O Cn M r O O O V' — ti 0 0 00 M V M �-- U) M O t` M Ih M O (V N M (o 0 O 01 OO O N (o M M LO I` N N M M Lo L (N7 T M V' O V' V M g M M U7 69 EA 69 EA 6% co 09 6916%1101 EA 69 (09 60 ti O O 00 tI- 1I- M (o U) w M— M w U) O O d' W N M Mq- h M U) N M O O M (O ti M (o N 'V' N O p COO M (f M N M? co M � M O M Oi V 11i -- O O O -- M M N ' M ') M — V V IN N 6A 1 EA 69 6A I U3,169, t4 69 6A 69 69 69 69 69 O O O O O M W (n r"T M M U) W O O O O V' M t-- -q- CD q- .-- M U7 U) 0 0 0 CD 't to M A N"T r- N CD M V' O V G (n M M N— `-' Lo M O O N _ M h N 'R 0 O 00 O N V (D 00 N M N N N N (f) M M T M M M N N M � 69 6A 6ti 69 6A 6A 6R 6A 6A 6A EA U) 6A 60 X 0 0 0 Lo CO ti CO U) O 00 — R M M O O U) r- O p I` — w IT U) V O 0 0 t` N (f) CD N N O Cn U) M m 0 0 ti 00 M 00 N lh (n Co N N d et T O M 00 Lf t` CV O N U) p OD M M M p M co 00 V [t T. M M U7 69 69 ER 6A 6A 609 6% 69 69 64), 69 6-) 69 6R M O M �; (n (D 0— r N (O (o M M 00 O CO O O (n N (O (D V U) U) M M O co V' U) 1` r t` w co M CC) O ti O O co U) 00 � 00 M CO O M O M U) to M U) � 1` F M M r fD CO V' (O 00 M a M U) OCI t-- M N 00 (n r- N N N M 00 M M N M M V N M V 6A era 64 6A 69 69 6A 69 69 6A 69 69 69 613, CO O N M IT O e- O O h N 00 r M 00 O O O M O— N M CM Nr N It CO O 00 U) — M M O V M M (O p (O O O V M CO N 'V' M p ti M CO — (n N .- (70 -! It r- 'IT w N t M O— N p IT U) M r- 00 O CD° N N N (o N N M N" co 00 N N M 69 69 6A 6A 64 69 69 6A co 61). 69 6A 69 60 J (o Il- J M M 0 _I N N N CU N N~ N N~ (1) () (6 ~ } } } } } }O } }O } } }O co 7 C C (D 0 M N C O 76 C_ C N (o N T N Q- 0 O ,T- 0 co O co O w O O 69 U N L E 7 C D O O co Lo 7 Q. O V EA V N N L 0 cn N a) co L U U m (n N E Q u) N O LL NO O Lu N � Q CL U Z (6 W U_ > Z [ifO W Cn U) Z Q Ir CL U) 2 WO CU Q Q U cn zo UO � W 0 0 N m (N c O N cQ. G O U / O /� ii O L- a. I le O O Ile Mi. W m O O a) FM .L d.d L U c O .N .v a> 13 � L) N 0) c > co O o d O N � U � U V O E O ca c U (D O yU Z Fu U U x 0 0 rn 00 (D U L)l 0 �0 0 m CO O N LO O cc ZCl) U m c� a� cr U d d CO CO 01 � � Q 0 o Z o 0 0 0 0) rn N O N � (a U �Qa M U L- j O M r LO O Q Q. d L 'U'^^ L J W 0 0 cD IT � ch > co o U N CO _ IN U) W LO 00 (D (3) 1- O OM M 0o (Y) 00 O O co F-- I O C:) 00 00 ti (3) cc o O O O O O 0 e- � U L U o d Z) c cn a) ca .... co 21 O Cn N L O c O U O 01 1 ti O N O O c c Q. Q O Q) U) U) O O E E .00 > > to cn 0 c c Q. Q. c 4= .r O O O N N L N � c o 0 a� U) r 06 U) N O U) o U L N U) O (6 II 0 O N 0 m U cn � -0 c U) � C W c = L) > M 2) m w Ln O c� O 0_ 0) L- O O E 0 Q1 Z 11 LO `O E O U a) O i- N ZT m J I I ai 0 0 U O O I— (L5 c O Z II O Q. O U O 0 LO N 0 L 00 � N N W CD i U) W U > Z W U Z Q U_ W U) �3 W0 0 U U_ (a 20 W c' H CL